New Watch Opinion: The Curious Case Of Seiko’s Upmarket Pivot

Since the quartz revolution/crisis in the 1970s, Seiko has established itself as one of the leading brands around the world. In fact, today it is arguably on par with Rolex in terms of brand recognition. What differentiates it from Rolex however, has always been the positioning of value as opposed to luxury. Where Rolex had marketed itself as the watch to have to mark every success, Seiko has largely made its name churning out exceptional value at every price point often letting the product speak for itself. From the highly affordable Seiko 5 line, the SKXes the solid divers (Prospex, Turtle & Samurai among others) and dress watches i.e. the Presage line, you would be hard-pressed to find a watch which failed to punch above its weight.  Even its luxury brand i.e. Grand Seiko (think Lexus vs Toyota), was extreme value for money with its extreme standards of Zaratsu polishing, uniquely designed dials and innovative technology e.g. the Spring Drive. The downside of Seiko’s constant over-performing watches however, was its value-for-money status was never on par with luxury Swiss watches like Rolex and therefore Seiko could not also command similar prices in the market.

Ariel at A Blog To watch covered these 2017 releases here

 

Since 2017, Seiko has made a very deliberate attempt to break out of the mold that it has historically been cast into. Where it had previously released watches that could unequivocally be said to be relatively affordable being in the sub-S$1,000 (€655) range, it began to announce pieces that interested buyers had to give pause to primarily because of the price. This was particularly apparent in its newly launched (in 2016) Presage line. It began tentatively, with a trio of enamel-dialed watches (SRQ023, SPB047, SPB049)  that cost upwards of S$1,100 (€720). It continued with a series of increasingly priced watches that just a month ago peaked at about S$4,000 (€2,620). Of course, being Seiko, always gave consumers just enough reason to rationalize the increased cost. Watches on the upside of S$1,000 (€655) was a steal because of the highly difficult to produce enamel dials which are typically more associated with haute horology. What about those that lacked enamel dials? Well, there was always the Byakudan-nuri application technique for Urushi lacquer that are extremely few masters of. Absent that, there was the “Baby Snowflake” dial on the SARX055 that allowed consumers to experience a taste of Grand Seiko, at a fraction of the cost. Then came 2018. In 2018, Seiko introduced a limited-edition stainless-steel watch that featured the same “Baby Snowflake” dial but with a new far thinner 6L35 movement. Admittedly, this improvement allowed for a sleeker more elegant watch. The premium however, was a steep S$1,500 (€982), more than double the earlier “Baby Snowflake” dial. This led to an outcry on forums and in the comment sections of watch publications regarding Seiko’s seeming move away from its historical “value for money” positioning. It is telling that this piece even till this day, has not sold out despite its production being limited to only 1,881 pieces. Nevertheless, even then, this steep increase in price could perhaps have been brushed off as payment for Seiko’s research and development of the new movement, one that resolves a major complaint from fans over the years, the relatively thick cases.

This year however, Seiko has seemingly doubled down on its strategy almost to the point of inexplicability. First, they launched two porcelain-dialed watches (SPB093 & SPB095) that retailed at about a S$150 (€98) less than the aforementioned limited-edition Baby Snowflake. That in and of itself may not have been too unexpected and arguably still in line Seiko’s more recent value proposition. After all, where else could you pick up a porcelain-dialed watch for S$2,650 (€1,735)? But Seiko did not stop there and just a month ago, released two new enamel-dialed watches (SJE075 & SJE077) that were also powered by its new movement, the 6L35. These two pieces were priced at almost S$4,000 (€2,620). Bear in mind, these came with leather straps as opposed to the steel bracelet on the limited-edition Baby Snowflake. Even then, it could be argued that enamel dials were more difficult to manufacture than the Baby Snowflake’s patterned dials and therefore priced at a premium.

Scottish Watches and TOCKR Watches

The real kicker, however, came just a week or so ago with Seiko’s latest releases, watches with references SNR037 and SNR039. They were two beautiful enamel-dialed watches powered by Seiko’s revolutionary Spring Drive movement the caliber 5R65. The caliber 5R65 is basically a less decorated, less well-finished version of the 9R65 caliber that is used in most Grand Seiko Spring Drive models. The price? A whopping S$6,600 (€4,324).

As a fan of Seiko and the wonderful value that it has offered in so many of its pieces, its current pricing strategy for these higher-end models is puzzling, to say the least. Whether by design or not, over the years Seiko has trained consumers like me, to quantify its price against the features that its watches offer. Applying that approach to these two new releases, the only justification for this exorbitant valuation by Seiko’s standards would be the fact that its Spring Drive movement is worth more than its thinner 6L35 movement. Then again, the blue Snowflake Grand Seiko that also comes on a leather strap with the better Zaratsu finishing and better decoration on its movement retails at about a similar S$6,600. Is an enamel dial actually worth all that much to then justify the price of these two new pieces when it has launched watches with enamel dials for less than S$1,000 (€655) i.e. the SARX027 that costs S$800 ((€524)? Perhaps it is a tad unfair to assess Seiko’s prices in this manner but I dare say Seiko has been a victim of its own success. The commonly used statement “You won’t find a watch with such features at this price anywhere else” still applies if we were comparing it to any other brand. However, the argument falls flat, ironically, against Seiko’s very own offerings.

Given that Seiko’s limited-edition Baby Snowflake has failed to sell out despite its limited production, and given the fact that one could easily get a Grand Seiko with a really cool dial and a better-finished case and movement for roughly the same price, I find it hard to believe that Seiko’s latest releases would gain much traction. It would require a very specific watch buyer that desired an enamel dial with a Spring Drive movement because every other combination exists in Seiko’s own line up for prices that are far more justifiable. This to me is a real shame because these new watches are really handsome looking watches.

The enamel dials, from the press pictures and assuming they are anything like the enamel dials on their previous models, are the real standouts, particularly in black. Produced by the master craftsman Mitsuru Yokosawa who has more than 40 years of experience in working with enamel, these enamel dials are truly works of art. When coupled with glossy black or white hands depending on the dial colour and simple Didoni font Arabic numerals, the overall look bears an elegant simplicity that is very much the hallmark of the late industrial designer Riki Watanabe. Even the date, a frequent point of criticism, is beautifully done with matching coloured date wheels that removes any distractions from the perfect sheen that the enamel gives off. And while the power reserve does detract somewhat from the symmetry of the dial, its presence adds grooves and texture that allows for an even greater play with light. The straight lugs of the case complement the industrial elegance of the look much better than curved lugs would have and adds to the old-school charm of the watch. Moreover, its 40mm size is also suitable for most people, though I am unfortunately not one of those people. And despite its rather dressy appearance, its 100m water resistance and super-hard case coating adds greatly to its versatility.

The choice of a Spring Drive movement though is questionable to me. No doubt, it is a fantastic movement that carries a completely smooth sweep of the second hand which fits perfectly with the smooth sheen of the white or black dials. Its accuracy is also unrivaled by any non-battery powered movements. However, assuming the Spring Drive movement was the main driver of the steep price, I believe that Seiko would have been better off outfitting it with one of its regular mechanical movements. The thinner 6L35 movement would not only have reduced the price but also allowed for a far thinner watch that would have perhaps been more fitting with such an elegant watch. If a Spring Drive had to be included with this piece, I would have far preferred this watch to be a part of Grand Seiko’s line up instead of being included as the pinnacle of the Seiko’s Presage line. It would have made the price far more palatable even if the Zaratsu finishing and a more decorated movement would have likely added to the cost. Given that Grand Seiko’s offerings do not feature enamel dials, it would also have plugged a gap for Grand Seiko and maintained Seiko’s value-for-money positioning.

Ultimately, these new Seiko Spring Drive watches as beautiful as they may be, are too poorly priced for them to be the hits we know Seiko is capable of. It is caught in no man’s land between Seiko and Grand Seiko and offers too little for even the most ardent fans to be able to justify the cost. It is understandable that Seiko wants to shift consumers’ perceptions especially given the amount of money exchanging hands in the luxury watch market currently. However, for it to successfully reposition itself, it would have to seriously reconsider the method it has been employing because these watches are not the answer, in my opinion.

Writer’s Disclaimer: All prices featured are what I can get these watches at over here in Singapore and the prices in Euros are conversions according to XE Currency as of 5 September 2019, 12:20AM GMT+8.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *