Lume And Gloom : Who Did It Better Panerai Or Porsche?

I love Panerai. I have always been a fan of their watches and have even visited the original store in Florence twice. The controversy regarding their history during the WW2 is definitely something to keep in mind, but just like BMW or Volkswagen, I would not hold them responsible for anything they did in the 40’s, 80 years later.

However, they should be held responsible for the mistakes they make today. Hear me out.

When I saw the new release of the Luminor with this insane lume and the cool factor that they managed to bring into their visuals, I was very excited. It turns out that lume seems to be a recurring theme in my life since Tockr of which I am the cofounder, launched an all hydro dipped lumed case collection a few days prior to the release of Panerai. So there is definitely something about lume in a watch that has a very big appeal to me.

Therefore, when I saw what Panerai was releasing, I surfed the web, including their Instagram to watch all the videos in order to appreciate their visuals and messages which I thought were very powerful. Then I came across that video on Instagram.

And it hit me. What have they done? How can they do something so blatantly wrong? Here is why I said that. I happen to be French and a subscriber of several French accounts of brands that I love, one of them being Porsche France.

Join the Scottish Watches Facebook Group here

A few months ago, Porsche released a commercial in France that I found to be brilliant, which is why I remember it so vividly. The commercial announced the new Porsche 911 using text that scrolled downwards as it was read by a voiceover. Then it was as if the video had been put into reverse and the same text began to scroll upwards as the voiceover read it from end to beginning. Reading the text in reverse made it even more powerful which I found was an incredibly intelligent and impactful way of sending a message. It stayed with me even long after I saw it. Fast forward to yesterday, as I am on Panerai’s Instagram, and what do I see? An obvious copy and paste of the creative Porsche released months before. I couldn’t believe my eyes! Β How dare they? Do they think that the rest of the world is clueless about advertising in other countries? Are they really going to take credit for this creative when it was clearly already done by one of the world’s most powerful and respected brands?

Compare and contrast

I started digging, watching all the Porsche videos of the 911 release and sure enough, there was the proof. The same sound effects, buzzing noises, the cadence of images appearing quickly like Polaroid shots, the jumpcuts of the Porsche 911, even the music, everything was identical to what Panerai did for their β€œnew” advertising campaign.

My disappointment was beyond belief. Is that the best that Panerai could do? To plagiarize someone else’s ideas? I even found the English language version of the Porsche commercial which I submit as exhibit B for evidence.

It took me only a few calls to people I know in Switzerland to learn that the person who oversaw that specific campaign used to work for Porsche. There you have it. What else is there to add? The videos speak for themselves. is it a case of inspiration or plagiarism? I’ll leave it up to you to decide.

 

 

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *